FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   ANALYZE DATA: Help with R | SPSS | Stata | Excel   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | Int'l Relations | Law & Courts
   FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | IR | Law & Courts
If this link is broken, please report as broken. You can also submit updates (will be reviewed).
Insights from the Field

State Supreme Courts Leverage Proximity and Prestige in Legal Precedent Transmission Study


legal precedent transmission
state supreme court citations
21st century judiciary
proximity effect
judicial prestige
Law Courts Justice
SPPQ
Dataverse
The Transmission of Legal Precedent Among State Supreme Courts in the 21st Century was authored by Rachael K. Hinkle and Michael J. Nelson. It was published by Sage in SPPQ in 2016.

Modern technology has transformed legal discourse across state supreme courts. This article examines how these changes impact judicial communication patterns by analyzing citation networks among all 52 state supreme courts from 2010 onwards.

The Problem: Understanding the diffusion of legal precedent remains an understudied area despite extensive research on legislative policy diffusion.

We address this gap while acknowledging Caldeira's foundational work, noting significant institutional and technological shifts since their original study.

Our Approach & Findings

Using a novel dataset tracking every citation in state supreme court decisions,

we investigated two key factors: geographical proximity between states and the prestige of cited courts.

Contrary to some assumptions about digital connectivity reducing regional differences, our analysis reveals:

Proximity Matters: Closer states are more likely to cite one another's precedents

Prestige Plays a Role: The higher the reputation of a court citing precedent, the more frequently it occurs across state decisions

Implications for Political Science Research

This study highlights how institutional structures and technological advancements shape legal discourse.

The findings suggest that despite increased connectivity through technology,

traditional regional influences persist in judicial communication networks.

data
Find on Google Scholar
Find on JSTOR
Find on Sage Journals
Podcast host Ryan Dataverse may be empty.